Friday, October 01, 2004


Examining Kerry's debate statements

"Saddam Hussein didn't attack us. Osama bin Laden attacked us. Al Qaeda attacked us."
-John Kerry

According to Kerry, we can only fight once we've been attacked.
- The Galvin Opinion

During the debate, John Kerry tried to get away with playing tricks with the truth. He hurled accusations, twisted facts, and made up arguments out of thin air. The Galvin Opinion has compiled and examined Kerry's statements. Here are the most egregious examples of how John Kerry did not level with the American people during Thursday night's debate with President Bush.

# 1: "The president made the judgment to divert forces from under Gen. Tommy Franks from Afghanistan before the Congress even approved it, to begin to prepare to go to war in Iraq."

TRUTH: Kerry has claimed that Gen. Tommy Franks complained about not having enough troops. That is not true. Franks has said he always had enough troops and the president never diverted troops from his forces.

# 2: "You don't send troops to war without the body armor that they need."

TRUTH: Kerry says the troops needed armor but he voted against the $87 billion to fund those troops in Iraq. He said he voted against the bill as a "protest."

# 3: "This president just, I don't know if he sees what's really happening there. But it's getting worse by the day."

TRUTH: Our brave soldiers are not losing. We are winning the war against a small but determined group of terrorists afraid of democracy flowering in Iraq.

# 4: "What kind of message does it send to be sending money to open firehouses in Iraq but we're shutting firehouses, who are the first responders here in America? The president hasn't put one nickel - not one nickel - into the effort to fix some of our tunnels and bridges and most exposed subway systems. That's why they had to close down the subway in New York when the Republican convention was there."

TRUTH: The president has increased funding. Homeland Security Department has paid more attention to infrastructure than all agencies ever before it. As for the subway, I took the subway to the Republican Convention, it wasn't closed.

# 5: "$200 billion, $200 billion that could have been used for health care, for schools, for construction, for prescription drugs for seniors."

TRUTH: But Kerry told Tim Russert that we should increase funding in Iraq. "We should increase it. By whatever number of millions of dollars it takes to win. It's critical that we are successful in Iraq."

# 6: "You know the president's father did not go into Iraq into Baghdad beyond Basra... And he said our troops would be occupiers in a bitterly hostile land. That's exactly where we find ourselves today."

TRUTH: At the time, no one wanted to send American ground troops into Iraq. It was hard enough for former President Bush to get approval to kick Iraq out of Kuwait. That's because people like John Kerry spoke out and voted against the Gulf War.

# 7: "We didn't guard the nuclear facilities."

TRUTH: Nuclear facilities. Exactly. So, they were in Iraq, Senator Kerry.

# 8: "And from the beginning I did vote to give the authority because I thought Saddam Hussein was a threat, and I did accept that intelligence."

TRUTH: Kerry said he thought Saddam was a threat but he also said, "And smart means not diverting your attention from the real war on terror in Afghanistan against Osama bin Laden and taking it off to Iraq where the 9/11 commission confirms there was no connection to 9/11 itself and Saddam Hussein."

# 9: "They avoided even the advice of their own general, General Shinseki, the Army chief of staff, said, you're going to need several hundred-thousand troops. Instead of listening to him, they retired him."

TRUTH: That is A LIE. According to Robert Novak, In March 2002 Donald Rumsfeld announced Shinseki's term would end in June 2003. Eleven months after that announcement, Shinseki told a committee that the U.S. would need "several hundred thousand soldiers."

# 10: "The terrorism czar, who has worked for every president since Ronald Reagan, said invading Iraq in response to 9/11 would be like Franklin Roosevelt invading Mexico in response to Pearl Harbor."

TRUTH: He's referring to a discredited liar, Richard Clarke, who exploited the tragedy of 9/11 with a maudlin apology at the Commission hearings.

# 11: "When the secretary general, Kofi Annan, offered the United Nations, he said, "No, no, we'll go do this alone.'' To save for Halliburton the spoils of the war, they actually issued a memorandum from the Defense Department saying, if you weren't with us in the war, don't bother applying for any construction."

TRUTH: The United Nations pulled out after their offices were bombed and UN officials like Sergio Vieira de Mello were killed. Halliburton, and companies from other countries that contributed troops, were allowed to bid for contracts. I guess John Kerry wants France to grab the spoils of war even though it did not shed blood with our troops.

# 12: "But what he has said is that even knowing there were no weapons of mass destruction, even knowing there was no imminent threat, even knowing there was no connection of Al Qaeda, he would still have done everything the same way."

TRUTH: While standing in front of the Grand Canyon, John Kerry said he would have gone to war with Iraq even though we haven't found WMD.

# 13: "First of all, we all know that in his State of the Union message he told Congress about nuclear materials that didn't exist."

TRUTH: That is ANOTHER KERRY LIE. Bush said in his speech that British intelligence found out Iraq attempted to buy materials from Niger. Another discredited liar, Joe Wilson, was the centerpiece of how the truth eventually emerged.

# 14: "The president said he would exhaust the remedies of the United Nations and go through that full process. He didn't. He cut it off, sort or arbitrarily."

TRUTH: President Bush, Colin Powell and Ambassador Negroponte went repeatedly to the U.N. Look up UN Resolution 1441 and you'll see how we had UN backing.

# 15: "We did not go as a last resort."

TRUTH: After 12 years of resolutions, expelled weapons inspectors and more resolutions, WE DID go to war as a last resort.

# 16: "Osama bin Laden uses the invasion of Iraq in order to go out to people and say America has declared war on Islam."

TRUTH: John Kerry quotes and agrees with Osama bin Laden. Well, what did Osama bin Laden use an excuse to kill us on 9/11? Was it our civilians fault?

# 17: "Saddam Hussein didn't attack us. Osama bin Laden attacked us. Al Qaeda attacked us."

TRUTH: It's not a zero sum gain. We can fight both Al Qaeda and Iraq. Osama bin Laden isn't the only terrorist in the world. And we had to attack Hussein before he attacked us. According to Kerry, we can only fight once we've been attacked.

# 18: "He also said Saddam Hussein would have been stronger. That is just factually incorrect. Two-thirds of the country was a no-fly zone when we started this war. We would have had sanctions. We would have had the U.N. inspectors. Saddam Hussein would have been continually weakening."

TRUTH: I thought Kerry said Saddam was a threat? Here he says Saddam was weakening. I don't know what Saddam could have possibly been weakening under when he was still killing people left and right while collaborating with terrorists like Zarqawi. Plus, Saddam kicked out UN inspectors repeatedly.

# 19: "If the president had shown the patience to go through another round of resolution, to sit down with those leaders, say, What do you need? What do you need now? How much more will it take to get you to join us? We'd be in a stronger place today."

TRUTH: What a pathetic negotiating tactic. Countries like France and Germany were intractable on this issue, and Kerry would have asked them what more they wanted of us? Unbelievable.

# 20: "But if and when you do it, Jim, you've got to do [pre-emption] in a way that passes the test. That passes the global test where your countrymen, your people understand fully why you're doing what you're doing."

TRUTH: According to Kerry, we have to pass a global test in order to assert our right of protecting ourselves through pre-emption.

# 21: "And we've watched this president actually turn away from some of the treaties there were on the table. You don't help yourself with other nations when you turn away from the global warming treating, for instance."

TRUTH: John Kerry voted against the Kyoto Global Warming Treaty.

Here are 21 instances of where Kerry obfuscated, manipulated facts and lied to the American people. There are many more instances of Kerry acting the same way throughout his debate performance. The Bush campaign would be well-served to highlight and criticize the galling comments and assertions that Kerry made.

Update: There is great debate coverage from fellow bloggers: Michelle Malkin, Outside the Beltway, Powerline, Reason's Hit and Run, Allah, LaShawn Barber, Rambling Journal, Tomas Kohl, Instapundit, Is that Legal, Spoons, , Political Wire, BitsBlog, CommandPost, Drink This, Spot On, Pejmanesque, Left Coast Conservative, Blogs for Bush, SlantPoint, and Vodka Pundit.

Add THE GALVIN OPINION to your Favorites

Add THE GALVIN OPINION to your blogroll

Update, There's More: "You can't stop him, you can only hope to contain him: Here are 12 more of Kerry's lies, wrong and misleading answers from the debate"



Kerry needed a decisive victory in the debate in order to catch up to Bush in the polls, but that didn't happen. He needed to make news in order to shake up the way the election is headed. While Kerry was poised and composed he was not emotional nor passionate enough to make enough voters move to his column. President Bush, with a calm demeanor, did not gain any voters either but it's unlikely he will lose many voters that could erode his lead.

The moderator, Jim Lehrer: Inexplicably, Lehrer made the whole debate a referendum on Bush, putting the president on the defensive. Kerry's senate career and his overall on philosophy on foreign policy issues were overlooked. Instead, there was a discussion of Bush's philosophy on foreign policy on issues like the Bush Doctrine and pre-emption. Kerry was asked open-ended questions so that he might be allowed to give his campaign stump speech.

Here are some of the "tough" questions that Lehrer asked Kerry

  1. "Do you believe you could do a better job than President Bush in preventing another 9/11-type terrorist attack on the United States?"
  2. "Colossal misjudgments, what colossal misjudgments, in your opinion, has President Bush made in these areas?"
  3. "As president, what would you do specifically in addition to or differently to increase the homeland security of the United States than what President Bush is doing?" (emphasis added)
  4. "You have repeatedly accused President Bush, not here tonight but elsewhere before, of not telling the truth about Iraq, essentially, of lying to the American people about Iraq. Give us some examples of what you consider to be his not telling the truth."

While Kerry was being asked open-ended questions, Bush was constantly put on the defensive by questions that constantly placed Iraq in a skeptical light. The questions mentioning John Kerry were loaded questions that asked if Kerry's election would mean more terrorists attacks or were about his character.

The challenger, John Kerry: No doubt about it, Kerry presented himself as something he's not; resolute on the tough issues. He told the American people that he has had the same position on Iraq. He questioned the president's fight against Al Qaeda when Kerry has opposed the death penalty for terrorists. Kerry was unrelenting and attacked Bush repeatedly.

The incumbent, President Bush: LIBERAL. Those were words you did not hear coming out of Bush's mouth. Perhaps Bush did not get a chance to bring up Kerry's liberal senate record on foreign policy because he was not given a chance to do so. Yes, Bush could have brought it up in some other way. However, Bush did a good job of reminding the American people that Kerry has flip-flopped on issues like Iraq and has sent mixed messages to our allies and enemies around the world. Bush spoke movingly of how the president's hardest decision is to send troops into harm's way.

Conclusion: The debate was a give-and-take on foreign policy issues. But, the debate doesn't end the "debate." The candidates will still talk about the important topics of terrorism, Iraq, Homeland Security until the final day of the campaign. The American people still have plenty of time to hear from the candidates about these issues. Kerry is behind Bush in the polls. He needed a major effort to make an impression on the American people on why he should be commander-in-chief. John Kerry failed in that mission.

Update: There is great debate coverage from fellow bloggers: Outside the Beltway, Powerline, Diggers Realm, Allah, LaShawn Barber, Rambling Journal, Captain's Quarters, Instapundit, Uptown Girl, Rough Woodsman, Spoons, Political Wire, BitsBlog, CommandPost, Baseball Crank, Karol, SISU, Steve Bragg, Blogs for Bush, and PoliBlog.



Sunday, Oct. 3
GREEN BAY 7 New York Giants
Philadelphia 9 CHICAGO
Washington 3 CLEVELAND
New England 5½ BUFFALO
Oakland 2 HOUSTON
Indianapolis 4 JACKSONVILLE
PITTSBURGH 4 Cincinnati
CAROLINA 3½ Atlanta
New Orleans 3 ARIZONA
New York Jets 5½ MIAMI
Denver 3 TAMPA BAY
SAN DIEGO Pick Tennessee
Monday, Oct. 4
BALTIMORE 5 Kansas City 41½

College Football
(3)GEORGIA 3 (13)Lsu
(8)TENNESSEE 2 (9)Auburn
(15)Purdue 3 NOTRE DAME
OREGON 3 (25)Arizona State

Rules: Send your picks before I post MY picks, Friday at 5pm. Choose who you think will beat the spread for each game. As a tiebreaker, predict the total points for the Monday night game. Tiebreaker decided by who comes closest to the total (regardless of over/under). E-mail your picks to GALVINOPINION at YAHOO dot COM. If you have a blog, give me your URL.

Update, Friday 6pm:
NFL - NYGiants, Chicago, Washington, New England, Houston, Jacksonville, Cincinnati, Atlanta, Arizona, NYJets, Denver, San Diego, San Francisco, Baltimore.

College - Georgia, Tennessee, Notre Dame, Arizona State.

NFL: 6-7-1
College: 5-1-1

Tom Galvin: 19-21-2
Quita: 8-13-0


This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?